Cattaraugus, NY homes for sale & real estate

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

11450 First St; Privately located at the very end of a dead end street, this hillside ranch home features, 2 possible 3 bedrooms with 2 full bathrooms and 1st floor laundry. The kitchen with stove and refrigerator, open to the dining room with walk-in pantry and living room. Great sized family room addition, with private access to a large back deck overlooking the almost 1 acre private yard. A second full porch adds to the enjoyment of the secluded outside space. Attached garage and back shed for extra storage. The 204 sq feet measured by agent family room is not reflected in the tax record square footage. Negotiations will begin May 6th.

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

Escape to serenity with this Amish-built cabin, crafted in 2019 and nestled on 18 pristine acres of rural bliss. This idyllic retreat offers an exceptionally quiet setting, perfect for those seeking peace and privacy, just over an hour from downtown Buffalo. Designed with equestrian enthusiasts, hobby farmers, or small-scale farm operators in mind, the property boasts a massive monitor barn (connected to NYSEG electric), a spacious accessory shed, and established raised bed gardens, complemented by a harmonious blend of wooded areas and open meadows. The cabin itself is a masterpiece of craftsmanship, constructed with insulated concrete forms for superior energy efficiency and durability. L

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

Welcome to 107 Thompson! This completely remodeled 4 bedroom 2 bath family home in the village of Little Valley. Located on a quiet residential street, walking distance to the new EBC Brewery and 10 minutes from Ellicottville. All of the work has been done for you. New siding, windows, doors, flooring, sub floor, carpeting, paint, furnace, kitchen, electrical, plumbing, completed 2025. Featuring a welcoming front porch, first floor master bedroom, bathroom, family room, LR with gorgeous original hard wood flooring and kitchen, plenty of storage space, laundry hook ups, new kitchen with loads of natural light, large living room for endless enjoyment. Upstairs offers 3 bedrooms and 1 full ba

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

This Spacious Colonial home has all the charm and character of a traditional home with all the modern amenities. There are 2 new forced air furnaces with central air, a new hot water tank, and all new appliances in the remodeled kitchen. The downstairs consists of a spacious living room with original hardwood floors, a gas fireplace, and beautiful original french doors that open into the formal dining room. The eat in kitchen has butcher block counters, luxury vinyl flooring with the half bath just around the corner, where you will also find stairs to the full basement and a door to the attached garage. Upstairs you will find 5 generous bedrooms, the spacious main bath, and laundry room wh

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

Charming 2-Unit Property in the Heart of the Village of Gowanda! Don't miss this fantastic opportunity to own a well-maintained duplex in a highly walkable and amenity-rich community. This adorable two-unit property features a durable metal roof, inviting front and side porches, ample parking, and a spacious yard — perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer looking to offset your mortgage with rental income, or an investor seeking a great addition to your portfolio, this property checks all the boxes. Located just steps from shops, restaurants, and local conveniences, this one won’t last long!

Cattaraugus, NY Homes for Sale

Turn key home that has been completely redone. Most furnishings are negotiable. Pack your bags and get ready to enjoy the Town of Little Valley. Little Valley offers a library, post office, laundromat, 3 restaurants, convenient location to The Pat McGee Trail, Allegany Park, and The Allegany Seneca Casino. A small portion of the property is in the Village of Little Valley. There is a small tax in addition to the Town of Little Valley taxes that are listed. This is in a vacation rental home program and has had very positive reviews! If you are looking for a second home close to Ellicottville's ski resorts, you are just a short drive away. WHAT IS HOLDING YOU BACK!