OPEN SAT, 3PM TO 5PM

For sale

$849,000

Est. $5,762/mo —

•

1,900

sq ft

124 Ithaca St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

About this home

Stunning Diamond High Ranch in Bay Shore – Fully Renovated from the Ground Up! This beautifully transformed home offers modern finishes, a bright and spacious layout, a gorgeous updated kitchen, stylish bathrooms, and generously sized bedrooms. The versatile lower level provides additional living space, perfect for entertaining, extended family, or a home office. Featuring a brand-new roof, siding, Andersen windows and sliding doors, new central air conditioning system, and in-ground sprinklers. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated, offering the perfect blend of style, comfort, and functionality. Truly turnkey living at its finest, just unpack and enjoy!

Single-familyProperty Type

1962Year Built

0.25 acresLot Size

$447Price/Sq.Ft.

2 car garageParking

Listing by Tammy Gatto • Signature Premier Properties

Contact: 631-673-3900

Listing updated: Oct 21, 2026 at 05:01am

Redfin checked: 3 minutes ago

•Source:OneKey® MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #1064788

Payment calculator

$5,762 per month

Principal and interest$4,749

Property taxes

$808

HOA dues

Home insurance

$205

Utilities

Add

5 minutes to get started. No credit impact.

Affordability tools

See this home in person

Open houses

Saturday, Oct 24

3:00pm - 5:00pm

Sunday, Oct 25

2:00pm - 3:00pm

Nearby open houses (10)

OPEN SAT, 11AM TO 1PM
$849,000
3 beds1.5 baths2,000 sq ft
21 Shelton Ct, Commack, NY 11725
Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
OPEN SAT, 11AM TO 1PM
$649,000
3 beds2 baths— sq ft
301 Lynn Ave, East Northport, NY 11731
Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 2PM
$999,999
5 beds3 baths2,768 sq ft
53 Cutter Pl, West Babylon, NY 11704
Listing by Netter Real Estate Inc
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 2PM3D WALKTHROUGH
$749,000
4 beds2 baths1,781 sq ft
413 Pecan St, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Listing by Above Board Real Estate Inc
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 1:30PM3D WALKTHROUGH
$599,316
3 beds2 baths1,392 sq ft
50 Peters Ln, North Babylon, NY 11703
Listing by Exit Realty All Pro
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 2PM
$610,000
3 beds1.5 baths1,708 sq ft
10 Francisco Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
Listing by OverSouth LLC
OPEN SAT, 12PM TO 2PM
$599,000
4 beds2 baths1,650 sq ft
81 Bushwick Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
OPEN SAT, 2PM TO 4PM3D WALKTHROUGH
$799,999
3 beds2 baths1,564 sq ft
7 Abby Dr, East Northport, NY 11731
Listing by EXP Realty
OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM
$539,000
3 beds1 bath900 sq ft
62 E 20th St, Huntington Station, NY 11746
Listing by Howard Hanna Coach
OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM
$599,999
5 beds3 baths1,900 sq ft
537 Lakeway Dr, North Babylon, NY 11704
Listing by Listing Pro Realty Services

Around this home

Schools

K - 12
Preschool & daycare

Commack Road Elementary School

Public 2-5 • Assigned • 0.9mi

4/10

Islip Middle School

Public 6-8 • Assigned • 1.7mi

5/10

Provided by GreatSchools

About

Islip

Islip, located between Great South Bay and the Connetquot River State Park Preserve, is a waterfront and suburban Brentwood neighborhood with salt-air marinas and leafy parkland. The neighborhood’s character concentrates around Main Street near Islip Avenue, where low-slung storefronts, cafés, and local services set a steady, walkable rhythm. Architectural cues lean toward mid-century ranches and Cape-style homes, with pockets of newer infill along wider arterials. Islip’s shoreline geography shapes weekends around docks, bay views, and boat traffic. Community pillars include the Bayard Cutting Arboretum, the historic Islip Art Museum, and the Sayville Ferry Service for Fire Island days. Rail service at Islip station adds a commuter cadence without overpowering the residential feel.

Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic

Market insights

124 Ithaca St · $849,000

DAYS ON MARKET

The average home goes pending in 31 days.

SALE-TO-LIST

Most homes are selling 2% above list price.

LIST PRICE

Median sale price in this area is $733,483. (14% lower than this home)

PRICE DROP

15% of homes in this area have had a price drop in the past month.

Property details

Interior
Exterior
Finance

Kitchen

Bathroom

Bedroom

Living

Interior features
Pull-stair attic access

Bathrooms
2 full bathrooms

Heating & cooling
Natural gas and other heating
Central air

Sale and tax history for 124 Ithaca St

Sale History
Tax History

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2017

$7,806 (+0.9%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2016

$7,736 (+2.5%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2015

$7,550 (−11.6%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2014

$8,539 (−10.5%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2013

$9,544 (+3.9%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2012

$9,181 (+3.6%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2011

$8,858 (+2.8%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2010

$8,616 (+4.1%)

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

2009

$8,277

$8,000 + $30,500

$38,500

Public record

Beds

—

Baths

—

Stories

—

Lot width

—

Lot depth

—

Lot size

0.25 Acres

Year renovated

—

Finished Sq. Ft.

1,764

Unfinished Sq. Ft.

—

Total Sq. Ft.

1,764

Year built

1962

Style

Single Family Residential

County

Suffolk County

APN

4728890500269000300019000

Parking Spaces

—

Basement

—

Accessible

—

HOA Dues

—

Garage

—

Features

—

Last updated by owner on Aug 31, 2026.

Climate risks

1/10 Flood Factor

Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years

1/10 Fire Factor

Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years

5/10 Heat Factor

7 days above 93° expected this year, 16 days in 30 years

6/10 Wind Factor

61% chance of strong winds in next 30 years

4/10 Air Factor

3 unhealthy days expected this year, 5 days in 30 years

Provided by First Street

Historical weather

Bay Shore, NY • 11706

Average low and high temperatures (°F)

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Sun exposure

94/ 100

Exceptional sunlight

Sunscore

This home ranks in the top 12% for direct sun exposure in Bay Shore. There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.

10.7 hrs

6.5 hrs

JuneDecember

Provided by Shadowmap

Redfin Estimate for 124 Ithaca St

We cannot show automated home-value estimates for this home.

Nearby homes have recently sold between $725,000 and $900,000.

Nearby comparable homes

The Redfin Estimate uses 6 recent nearby sales, priced between $725K to $900K.

SOLD AUG 17, 2026
$900,000 Last sold price
5 beds2.5 baths2,132 sq ft
52 41st St, Islip, NY 11751
Listing by Coldwell Banker Easton Prop
$25/sq ft
2 years newer
SOLD APR 30, 2026
$725,000 Last sold price
4 beds1.5 baths1,888 sq ft
109 Utica St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
$63/sq ft
larger lot
SOLD SEP 30, 2026
$785,000 Last sold price
3 beds2 baths1,651 sq ft
194 Missouri Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Listing by First Realty Properties Inc
$28/sq ft
smaller lot
SOLD OCT 12, 2026
$801,000 Last sold price
4 beds2 baths2,674 sq ft
36 Richmond St, Islip, NY 11751
Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$147/sq ft
smaller lot
5 years older
SOLD JUN 16, 2026
$755,000 Last sold price
6 beds3 baths2,226 sq ft
27 Trader Ln, Brentwood, NY 11717
Listing by Signature Premier Properties
$108/sq ft
larger lot
2 years newer
SOLD JUL 2, 2026
$770,000 Last sold price
4 beds2 baths1,808 sq ft
42 Greenwood Rd Unit Bay Shore, NY 11706, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Listing by Yes Homes Realty Ltd
$21/sq ft
35 years older
basement

Tour for free, no strings attached

Make a winning offer with the help of a local agent

Ask a question

(631) 318-8243