* * FULLY FURNISHED * * Welcome to 5544 Sugartown Rd, your fully updated and turn-key retreat in the heart of Great Valley. Currently used as a successful short term rental, this fully updated 4-bedroom, 3 full bath home has been thoughtfully renovated throughout, combining comfort, style, and functionality-easily accommodating an astonishing 16 guests. Recent improvements just this past year include a new well tank, new water softener system, new hot water tank, and a 4-stage filtration system for well water-providing peace of mind for years to come. The home also features newly renovated bathrooms and a brand-new hot tub, creating the ideal space to relax after a day outdoors or to boost income potential for short term stays. Extensive upgrades and improvements have been made throughout this home over the years, too many to fully capture in one description. With all of the hand-crafted furnishings and necessities included, this property is truly move-in ready or primed for immediate short-term rental use. Located just minutes from Ellicottville’s ski country, Holiday Valley, and year-round attractions including shopping and dining, it’s perfectly positioned for both personal enjoyment and income potential. Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a cash-cow investment property, this is the perfect option. VR Pricing, Seller will entertain offers from $479,900-$529,900
Single-familyProperty Type
1940Year Built
0.49 acresLot Size
$223Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listing by Mikayla Seiberg• Realty One Group Empower
VR Pricing Seller will entertain offers between $450,000-$499,900. Welcome to 5544 Sugartown Rd in Great Valley, NY! This stunningly remodeled 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home is a perfect blend of modern comfort and rural charm. Thoughtfully designed, this property features efficient mini splits for heating and air conditioning, ensuring year-round comfort. Currently set up as a successful short-term rental, it offers a fantastic investment opportunity, but its spacious layout and cozy atmosphere also make it an ideal primary residence. Located just minutes from the vibrant village of Ellicottville, you'll enjoy easy access to premier ski resorts, boutique shopping, and fine dining, making it a fantastic base for both seasonal getaways and everyday living. The interior is beautifully updated with high-end finishes, creating a warm and inviting ambiance. Every piece of furniture and decor inside is available for purchase separately, making this home truly turnkey. Enjoy serene surroundings and the convenience of being close to local amenities and attractions. Don't miss out on this versatile gem! Showings and negotiations start immediately. Tour today and envision the endless possibilities this remarkable property offers!
Public Records
Sep 13, 2022
Sold
$350,000
$162/sq ft
WNYREIS #B1402682
Aug 5, 2022
Sold
$350,000
$162/sq ft
May 15, 2022
Pending
—
May 12, 2022
Listed
$299,900
$139/sq ft
WNYREIS #B352552
Nov 1, 2011
Sold
$25,000
$12/sq ft
Dec 30, 2009
Listed
$47,900
$22/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$7,095
$13,800 + $421,100
$434,900
2025
$7,095 (+262.4%)
$13,800 + $421,100
$434,900
2024
$1,958 (−2.8%)
$10,400 + $66,900
$77,300
2023
$2,015 (+2.2%)
$10,400 + $66,900
$77,300
2022
$1,972 (+3.2%)
$10,400 + $66,900
$77,300
2021
$1,911 (+55.4%)
$10,400 + $66,900
$77,300
2020
$1,230 (+0.7%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2019
$1,221 (+6.4%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2018
$1,148 (−15.0%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2017
$1,350 (+13.1%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2016
$1,194 (+3.6%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2015
$1,152 (+0.2%)
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
2014
$1,150
$10,400 + $38,400
$48,800
Public record
Beds
4
Baths
3
Stories
1
Lot width
143 ft.
Lot depth
150 ft.
Lot size
0.49 Acres
Year renovated
1993
Finished Sq. Ft.
2,156
Unfinished Sq. Ft.
—
Total Sq. Ft.
2,156
Year built
1940
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Cattaraugus County
APN
044400A05600300020190000000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 11, 2026.
Climate risks
1/10 Flood Factor
Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years
1/10 Fire Factor
Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years
1/10 Heat Factor
7 days above 89° expected this year, 18 days in 30 years
1/10 Wind Factor
Minimal risk of severe winds over next 30 years
1/10 Air Factor
0 unhealthy days expected this year, 0 days in 30 years
Provided by First Street
Historical weather
Great Valley, NY • 14741
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
23
12
29
15
47
28
57
36
61
43
74
55
78
59
74
53
72
48
59
38
44
31
31
18
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
92/ 100
Exceptional sunlight
Sunscore
This home ranks in the top 16% for direct sun exposure in Great Valley. There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.
9.7 hrs
5.8 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Redfin Estimate for 5544 Sugartown Rd
We cannot show automated home-value estimates for this home.
Nearby homes have recently sold between $360,000 and $530,000.
Nearby comparable homes
The Redfin Estimate uses 5 recent nearby sales, priced between $360K to $530K.