We survey our customers, whether a deal succeeds or fails, and show you their reviews. Learn More
Redfin Agent
Cal DRE #: 01991173
All Reviews
All2024 (1 Home)
Tony was fantastic to work with. He was extremely patient, easy-going, and down to earth, yet moved quickly when it came time to make an offer. Additionally, he was very helpful in making recommendations for people to help with various updates we wanted to make after taking possession of our new house.
House buyer closed Mar '24
8796 Logan Place, Cotati, CA
8796 Logan Place, Cotati, CA
$1.8M • 4 Bed, 3 Bath, 3830 Sq. Ft. • Multiple offers
2022 (3 Homes)
We accomplished both selling, and buying, houses with Tony's professional guidance and knowledge. Tony led us through the process, from the very start, to the very last task, always contributing the best advice. Tony was an absolute pleasure to work with, and definitely eased my anxiety over the home selling, and buying process.
Tony is a real professional. We had a number of complexities in our sale, including simultaneously purchasing another home. Tony handled all questions and issues promptly, accurately, and with urgency when needed. I would definitely recommend Tony.
Tony is a high-integrity realtor - he really wants you to be happy with your purchase, and he goes above and beyond to help. He also has a wide network of contacts in Sonoma County which come in handy for finding good mortgage brokers, home repairs, etc. I had a great experience working with Tony and will gladly work with him again in the future.
2021 (4 Homes)
Another great transaction with Tony! Best agent in Sonoma County!!
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
Another great experience with Tony - sold the house off-market relying on his great network of connections - got over-ask and transaction went smoothly. Already working with Tony on the next project in a crazy market.
Great help in my search for an investment property! Tony is very knowledgable about the area, understands the investors perspective, is patient and professional. Went well above normal service and continues to help even after the deal is done.
Multi-family home buyer closed Apr '21
2900 - 2908 Tachevah Dr, Santa Rosa, CA
2900 - 2908 Tachevah Dr, Santa Rosa, CA
$900K • 5 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 2489 Sq. Ft.
2020 (10 Homes)
Boy is Tony good at what he does. This man was extremely friendly, and never made us feel as if we were a hassle when asking him to view homes. He was always available, regardless of the time for any questions that we had. Covid made things a bit more tricky when it came to viewing homes, but Tony made the experience way to easy. He gives back great feedback on homes, and makes sure that the home you are looking for is one that will fit all your needs. Tony might be young, but has the real estate career down. If you are looking for an available, easy going, and friendly agent Tony is the guy for you. This man has a bright future ahead of him!
House buyer closed Dec '20
5190 Quayle Ln, Sebastopol, CA
5190 Quayle Ln, Sebastopol, CA
$725K • 3 Bed, 2 Bath, 1320 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
Tony is a great realtor and I'm looking forward to working with him again. He's detailed-oriented, honest, and was one step ahead of most everything I could think of. He's got great experience, insight, and plenty of connections in the area that came in handy through the process. I would highly recommend him if you want a smooth and thorough real estate experience!
Easy manner, flexible, very knowledgeable, good communication. He is a delight to work with.
Customer did not leave review comments.
Tony was fantastic to work with and kept me informed during the whole process, and especially after close of escrow!
Multi-family home buyer closed Jun '20
229 231 West 6th St, Santa Rosa, CA
229 231 West 6th St, Santa Rosa, CA
$720K • 6 Bed, 2 Bath, 2162 Sq. Ft.
This was the easiest, smoothest transaction I’ve ever experienced. I will recommend Tony to everyone I know looking to buy or sell a home. He made us feel like family. I will definitely be using him again.
This home purchase was a long process for us and Tony Natoli was with us every step of the way! He offered guidance and support throughout the process, which we truly appreciated. His expertise reassured us that the outcome would be favorably , and we were not disappointed.
Tony helped us buy our second home in Santa Rosa. I happened to be driving by, and saw a "for sale" sign in a neighborhood that was one of our top choices to live. I did not see the listing online yet, so I contacted Tony, and within minutes, he contacted the listing agent to get us some details. The home was just what we wanted, and within hours after seeing it, Tony had a competitive offer to the seller and the next morning they accepted. Tony set up all the inspections and they were all completed on time, which was amazing considering the stress and lack of resources due to COVID19. We had no issues staying on track with our contract, because of Tony's diligence and expertise. After doing all of our inspections, there was some negotiating that needed to be done for some repairs. With... Show More
Customer chose not to leave public comments.
Land buyer closed Jan '20
241 Middle Rincon Rd, Santa Rosa, CA
241 Middle Rincon Rd, Santa Rosa, CA
$745K • 4 Bed, 3 Bath, 1933 Sq. Ft. • New construction • First-time buyer
Tony was a pleasure to work with. He was very helpful and knowledgeable. He was also always kind and reassuring. We bought our new home on contingent of sale, and our buyer bought our previous home on contingent of sale. He worked tirelessly with all the agents to assist in the buying/selling process. We couldn't have done it without him. Thank you, Tony!
Multi-family home seller closed Jan '20
1280 Giffen Pl, Santa Rosa, CA
1280 Giffen Pl, Santa Rosa, CA
$675K • 4 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 2325 Sq. Ft.
2019 (7 Homes)
I was referred to Tony a few years ago by a good friend of mine and let me tell you, he is an amazing person. He helped my wife and I purchase our very first home. After a few years passed by, he was there to help sell our property. Words can’t describe how blessed we are to have Tony not only as our agent, but as a family friend! You won’t be disappointed!
Tony Natoli is a professional and a delight to work with. Our home buying experience was transparent and simplified due to Tony's knowledge and expertise. Tony was an integral part in making our new home a reality. Thank you, Tony!
House buyer closed Nov '19
3217 Meadow Glen Dr, Santa Rosa, CA
3217 Meadow Glen Dr, Santa Rosa, CA
$730K • 3 Bed, 2.5 Bath, 1906 Sq. Ft. • First-time buyer
Professional, direct, and effective buyer’s agent. Would use again.
We decided to put our home on the market at the end of October and were a little concerned that because of the time of year, going into the holidays, we might have trouble selling it. We met with Tony and he immediately put our minds at ease. He got to work right away, and gave us some helpful guidance on how to prepare our home for the sale. From the beginning, it was evident that he knew what he was doing. He was extremely knowledgeable and thorough in guiding us through the process of preparing and listing our home. He put a lot of time and care into researching and preparing a package for us about how he came up with the listing price and what we could expect, and we felt confident that because of his experience and integrity, this would be a smooth process. I appreciated his... Show More
Tony Natoli is the best. Not only did he help us buy our home he helped us sell it. I was working a lot and needed to move pretty quickly for a job offer in another state. He came over and helped my family clean and paint our house. Tony is one of the most kind hearted person I’ve ever met. I’ve bought and sold homes for years but no one helped as much as he did. He did everything to get us the best selling price. I’m happy to recommend him to anyone for anything. That’s the type of person he is.
Customer did not leave review comments.
House buyer closed Apr '19
1903 Fountainview Cir, Santa Rosa, CA
1903 Fountainview Cir, Santa Rosa, CA
$935K • 4 Bed, 3 Bath, 2219 Sq. Ft. • New construction
Tony is easy to work with, great guy, makes the home buying/selling process smooth and is also helpful and knowledgeable. He was there to answer any questions we had in timely fashion, and genuinely cares about his clients.
2018 (1 Home)
Dear Madam or Sir, Tony helped me buy a long term rental property for my retirement. He knew that this meant my out-of-pocket was crucial to protect my future. When the right house came along he took the time to show me the value of this home in that neighborhood and condition, which was $5,000 below asking, then helped me write a compelling offer using terms instead of money. Tony delivered on all our time frames by referring me his quick lender and inspector partners. It was clear he knew how to navigate his way through a transaction and communicate what was happening and why. Tony ultimately renegotiated another $20,000 off the price which is better than I could have hoped for. I am so glad to have found Tony, and the tenants he later found for my rental have been just as wonderful... Show More